STRATEGY

Klaviyo signup form not showing on Shopify? How to fix it

When a Klaviyo signup form isn't showing on Shopify, it's usually one of three things: the form isn't Live, the Klaviyo app embed is switched off in your current theme, or the form's targeting and display rules are hiding it from you. Check the form's status first, then the app embed, then test in a fresh incognito window with ad blockers off, because you've probably already closed or submitted it in your normal browser.

Jack White
Jack White Founder, Bardown Digital
Updated · 10 min read
KEY TAKEAWAYS
  • On the Sign-up forms page, the Status column should say Live. "Editing" means you have unpublished changes, and Draft means it isn't published at all.
  • On Shopify, forms need the Klaviyo app embed turned on in your published theme. Change themes and you have to turn it on again.
  • Test in a new incognito or private window with ad blockers disabled. Frequency settings remember that you closed or submitted the form.
  • Audience rules like "Show to any existing profile" or list-based targeting won't fire for visitors Klaviyo can't identify, including your own incognito test.
  • Klaviyo's "Preview on website" skips targeting and display rules, so use it to check the design, not to prove the form is set up right.

This is for Shopify founders who built a popup, hit publish, and can't see it on their own site. Work through it in this order.

Is the form actually live?

Start here, because it's the fastest fix. Go to Website, then Sign-up forms, and look at the Status column. Klaviyo uses three statuses:

  • Live: published.
  • Editing: live, but with changes you haven't published yet.
  • Draft: not published, including forms you've taken offline.

If you edited a live form, the changes don't reach your site until you publish again. Klaviyo's steps: click Publish or schedule, select Publish now, confirm with Publish now, then refresh your site and test again.

Two other things that catch people:

  • A schedule. A scheduled form shows "Scheduled" in the Status column, with the date and time it will go live or return to draft. If someone set a "Stop showing" time, the form goes back to draft at that time.
  • Alerts. Errors listed under Alerts in the editor header can block publishing. Fix those first.

If you run Klaviyo from inside your Shopify admin (Klaviyo's "Klaviyo in Shopify" experience), its troubleshooting page says the free plan allows one live sign-up form there. Setting a second one live sets the other back to Draft.

Is the Klaviyo app embed turned on in your Shopify theme?

This is the big one for Shopify. Klaviyo says enabling onsite tracking "allows you to use Klaviyo sign-up forms on your site," and on Shopify that runs through the Klaviyo app embed. No app embed, no popup.

To turn it on from Klaviyo, per Klaviyo's onsite tracking guide:

  1. Go to Integrations and click Shopify.
  2. In the Onsite Tracking section, check "Track behavioral events" and click Update Settings.
  3. If the app embed is off, click "Turn on." That opens your Shopify theme editor.
  4. Open App embeds, switch the Klaviyo app embed on and click Save.
  5. Back in Klaviyo, refresh the page. A green banner confirms it's enabled.

From the Shopify side, Shopify's own steps are: Online Store, Edit theme on the theme you want, click the App embeds icon in the sidebar, toggle the app on and click Save. In the Klaviyo in Shopify app, Klaviyo calls the toggle "Klaviyo Onsite Javascript."

The gotcha is themes. Klaviyo says to enable the app embed "on your store's current theme," and Shopify says if you change your published theme you'll need to re-activate apps "as they won't be active by default." So if your popup vanished the day you launched a new theme, this is almost certainly why. Also make sure you edited the published theme, not a draft copy.

If the embed looks fine but tracking still seems off, read Klaviyo Shopify sync problems next.

Are you testing it the right way?

A lot of "my form is broken" is really "I already saw it." Klaviyo's frequency settings live under Targeting & behavior, then Display, then Frequency:

  • "If visitor closes form, show again after __ day(s)." If you closed it while checking the design, it won't come back until that many days pass.
  • "Don't show again if form was submitted or if go to URL button was clicked." If you submitted a test email, you're done seeing it in that browser.

Klaviyo says these rely on data stored in your browser, so a new incognito window resets them. Klaviyo's testing steps are to exit any active preview, open your site in a new incognito or private window with ad blockers disabled, meet the form's display rules, then submit with test contact details. Klaviyo also notes that ad blockers can stop forms from displaying or submitting, so a visitor running one may never see your popup at all.

And use an email you haven't used on that form before. Entering a new email doesn't reset who the browser thinks you are.

Why does the preview work but the live site doesn't?

Because the preview cheats on purpose. In the editor, "Preview on website" lets you open the form on a page of your site, and Klaviyo says preview mode "bypasses targeting and display rules." Preview links also expire after 30 minutes.

So if the form shows in preview and not live, the design is fine. The problem is the publish status, the app embed, or the rules below.

Are your targeting and timing rules hiding the form?

Open the form and go to Targeting & behavior. Check each of these.

Timing. Under Display, then Timing, a form set to "Based on rules" waits for its triggers: exit intent, a time delay, a scroll depth or a number of pages viewed. If "Only display if all selected conditions are met" is on, every rule has to happen. Klaviyo's example is 60% scroll and exit intent. If you're on a phone or a short page, you may never hit both. Turn that setting off and any one rule will trigger it.

Audience. This is where testing gets confusing. The options include "Don't show to existing Klaviyo profiles," "Show to all audience members," "Show to any existing profile," "Show to email only subscribers," "Show to text messaging only subscribers" and "Show to specific profiles in a list or segment." If your form targets existing profiles or list members, an incognito window counts as an unidentified visitor and won't qualify. If it's set to "Don't show to existing Klaviyo profiles" and you're already a subscriber in your normal browser, you won't see it there either.

URLs. "Only show on certain URLs" and "Don't show on certain URLs" match by "Containing" or "Exactly matching." An exact match needs the full address, including https://. One typo and the form never matches.

Devices. The options are "All devices," "Desktop only" or "Mobile only." A desktop-only form won't show on your phone, though Klaviyo says it does show on tablets.

Other forms. If "Don't show multiple forms at the same time" is on and two forms qualify, the one with the higher display priority shows first. Klaviyo says that with equal priorities, "the order is not guaranteed." Your new popup may be losing to an old one.

Partly. Klaviyo says that based on your Shopify Customer Privacy settings, it may not track onsite events for visitors in the EU, EEA, UK and Switzerland unless they've given consent. Those visitors are treated as anonymous, which changes who sees what:

  • "Don't show to existing Klaviyo profiles" still shows the form, since the visitor isn't identified.
  • "Show to all audience members" allows them.
  • "Show to any existing profile," "Show to email only subscribers," "Show to text messaging only subscribers," and list or segment includes won't show to them.
  • Location and device targeting still work.

If most of your traffic is in those regions and your popup targets known profiles, your real reach can be much smaller than you think. For more on how Klaviyo recognizes visitors, see how Klaviyo identifies anonymous visitors.

Could an A/B test be the reason?

It can explain why you see a different version than you expected. Klaviyo says visitors are cookied the first time they view a test form and "will only ever see that variation," unless they clear cookies or use an anonymous window. Variations can also use different display timing, so one version might wait for exit intent while the other shows on scroll.

Creating a test doesn't change the form's status. A draft stays a draft. When a test finishes, the winning form goes live.

Is a second Klaviyo account or a caching issue involved?

Two accounts. Klaviyo says only one account should supply the onsite code. If you have a second Klaviyo account, turn off "Automatically add Klaviyo onsite JavaScript" there. On Shopify, check which account is connected through the app embed. A form built in the wrong account won't show.

Caching. Klaviyo's help pages don't describe a separate form cache to clear. Their fix after any change is to publish again, refresh your site and test in a fresh incognito window. Shopify also notes it can take a moment to register theme changes, so give the app embed a minute before you panic.

Once it's showing, is it set up to make money?

Getting the popup on screen is step one. Two things I'd check right after:

Opt-in. I use single opt-in for email. A non-customer from a cold ad heading into the welcome series shouldn't hit extra layers that may stop an order. Klaviyo's troubleshooting page notes that with double opt-in, subscribers aren't added until they confirm, so your list can look smaller than your form submissions. More on that in Klaviyo double opt-in.

The offer. Brands offering cash back on the signup popup instead of a discount see 10 to 20% higher first-order profit, because non-customers place that first order without a discount. I break down that choice in should your email popup offer a discount. Then check whether the form converts well enough in what's a good signup form conversion rate.

FAQ

Why is my Klaviyo popup not showing on Shopify?

Check that the form's status is Live, that the Klaviyo app embed is on in your published theme, and that you're testing in a new incognito window with ad blockers off. Then review timing, audience, URL and device rules.

Why did my Klaviyo form disappear after I changed my Shopify theme?

App embeds aren't active by default in a new theme. Open the theme editor, go to App embeds, switch Klaviyo on and save.

Why does my form show in preview but not on my site?

Klaviyo's preview mode bypasses targeting and display rules. If it works there, check the publish status, the app embed and your rules.

Why can't I see my Klaviyo form even in incognito?

An incognito visitor is unidentified. Forms set to show only to existing profiles, subscribers, or list or segment members won't appear. Also check that you meet every timing rule if "Only display if all selected conditions are met" is on.

Do ad blockers stop Klaviyo forms?

Klaviyo says ad blockers can stop forms from displaying or submitting. Turn yours off when testing.

Jack White, founder of Bardown Digital
WRITTEN BY Jack White

Founder of Bardown Digital, a Chicago-based Klaviyo email and retention agency for Shopify brands. He's worked with brands doing $500K to $100M a year, with $100M+ in email-attributed revenue across them.

SOURCES

Keep reading

All posts →
STRATEGY · 10 MIN READ

How to raise average order value with email

Raise average order value with email: second products in the reorder reminder, per-product cross-sells, free shipping thresholds and bundles, timed right.

Read the post →
STRATEGY · 10 MIN READ

Klaviyo RFM segmentation: recency, frequency and money, explained

How Klaviyo's RFM analysis scores customers, the six groups it uses, what plan you need, and how to build RFM-style segments yourself without it.

Read the post →
STRATEGY · 10 MIN READ

How to grow your SMS list without burning it

How to grow your SMS list on Shopify with Klaviyo: two-step popups, checkout opt-in, text-to-join keywords, double opt-in and what to text new subscribers.

Read the post →

Want me to check your forms?

A popup that doesn't show is lost signups every day, and a popup that shows with the wrong offer costs you margin. The first strategy session is free: one hour, live with me in your Klaviyo account, and you leave with a fix list even if we never work together. Not ready to book? Grab one of my free resources instead.

Book a strategy session
Or email me at jackwhite@bardowndigital.com