- Average order value is total revenue divided by number of orders. Email raises it by changing what's in the cart, not by sending more emails.
- Start with what makes sense next in the customer's lifecycle: another flavor, an accessory or a different product.
- The reorder reminder is a great place for an "add a second flavor to this order" line. Keep it a line, not the headline.
- My default for cross-sells is a specific flow per product, not one email full of dynamic product blocks.
- Free shipping thresholds and bundles work when the math works. Shopify's own guidance is to set the threshold from your real shipping cost and margin, then test it.
This is for Shopify founders selling consumables who already have the basic flows running and want each order to be worth a little more.
What is average order value, and can email raise it?
Average order value (AOV) is your total revenue divided by your number of orders. Shopify's reports use a slightly cleaner version: gross sales minus discounts, divided by orders, leaving out taxes, shipping and later returns.
Email can't change your prices, but it can change what people put in the cart and when they're asked. Shopify's own list of ways to raise AOV includes order minimums for free shipping and gifts, bundles, upselling or cross-selling complementary products, loyalty programs with spending thresholds, and product recommendations. Almost every one of those can be delivered by email.
For context, Shopify cites Dynamic Yield benchmarks putting average order value around $81 for food and beverage, $71 for beauty and personal care, and $48 for consumer goods. Don't chase someone else's number. Compare yourself to your own last 90 days.
If you want the bigger picture, AOV is one of the three levers in how to increase customer lifetime value with email. For most consumable brands, more orders is still the biggest lever. Bigger orders is the one people forget to pull.
Which emails raise order value the most?
Three places do most of the work.
1. The reorder reminder. This is the email where someone is already planning to buy. I'm fine adding a line like "add a second flavor to this order" inside the reorder reminder. That's an easy bump in order size from someone who's already said yes to the first product.
Keep the add-on small, though. The reorder email's main job is getting them more of what they love, and it's worth protecting. Across 4 brands I work with, replenishment flows earned $2.23 per person, about 28x the best campaign, and only 2 of the 4 had one built. A second-flavor line can ride along with that. It shouldn't take over. Here's how to set up a Klaviyo replenishment flow if you don't have one yet.
2. Cross-sell flows. I build cross-sells as standalone flows and use them in post-purchase or customer winback contexts. Overlap with your other post-purchase emails isn't a problem. The first step is always the same: think about what makes sense next in the customer's lifecycle, whether that's another flavor, an accessory or a different product, and put it in front of the average customer. The full build is in my cross sell email flow guide.
3. Order-value offers in your existing flows and campaigns. A free shipping threshold, a bundle or a "buy two" offer gives people a reason to add one more thing. More on how to set those up below.
Should I build one cross-sell flow per product or use dynamic recommendations?
My default is a specific version of the cross-sell flow for each product. Build one layout and setup that works, then duplicate it for each item. The buyer of product A gets an email about product B, written for that exact pair, so the copy can say why B goes with A.
The alternative is one general cross-sell flow. It gets more sends because every buyer goes through it, and it shows you which products people buy at a given point in the customer lifecycle. That's useful if you don't know your natural pairs yet.
What I don't lead with is one email stuffed with dynamic product blocks and hoping the right thing shows up. A clear pick written for the customer beats a grid of guesses. If you do want to see how Klaviyo's recommendation features work, I cover them in Klaviyo product recommendations.
When should you ask for the bigger order?
This is where most brands get it wrong. They push the add-on the day after the first order and wonder why people tune out.
- Accessories: later. Recommend accessories later after the purchase so you're not hounding the customer. Let them use the main product first.
- Restock products: not too soon. If the second product is something they'll use up, don't ask for another purchase before they've had a real chance to get through the first one.
- Around a month in, for consumables. One pattern from our data: at 30 to 40 days, the post-purchase thank-you email earned much higher revenue per recipient than the customer winback, likely because customers are ready to restock sooner than the winback assumes. That window is a good time to suggest a bigger order, because they're already thinking about the next one.
If you're not sure when your customers run out, look at how long they actually wait between orders. I walk through that in replenishment email timing.
Should I use a free shipping threshold in my emails?
If the math works, yes. Shopify's free shipping guide says a minimum purchase threshold "gives customers an incentive to increase their cart value to avoid shipping costs." It also cites AlixPartners research finding 56% of retailers require a minimum order value for free shipping.
The trap is picking a number that sounds nice. Shopify's worked example: a store with a $40 AOV, $8 average shipping cost and 40% gross margin tests a $45 threshold. The extra $5 in the cart adds about $2 in gross profit, which still leaves $6 of shipping uncovered. So either the threshold goes higher or the brand decides it can absorb the rest. Shopify's advice is to estimate real shipping costs first and test against conversion, AOV and profit margin.
In Shopify, a free shipping discount can carry a "Minimum purchase amount" or a "Minimum quantity of items" requirement, as a code or an automatic discount. Once it's live, email is where you tell people about it:
- Campaigns: say the threshold plainly in the subject line or the first line. People should know what they get and where.
- Flows: Klaviyo's show/hide logic lets a block appear only to people who meet a condition on the trigger event. Klaviyo's own example is a Placed Order flow where the block shows only when Placed Order Value is greater than 100. You can use the same idea to show different messages to bigger and smaller orders.
- Abandonment: Klaviyo's flow splits can use conditions based on the trigger event, such as the value of the order that started the flow. That lets you send carts under your threshold a "you're $X away from free shipping" nudge and leave bigger carts alone.
Shopify's guide also mentions a brand that set a minimum quantity of two bottles per order instead of a dollar threshold. For a consumable brand with one hero product, "free shipping on two" can be simpler to say than "free shipping over $55."
Do bundles and tiered offers work in email?
They can, and they fit consumables well. A bundle answers the question "which one should I try?" by letting people try more than one.
On Shopify, the free Shopify Bundles app lets you create fixed bundles and multipacks from your admin. For tiered or "buy more" offers, Shopify's Buy X get Y discount lets you set the "Customer buys" side to a minimum quantity of items or a minimum purchase amount. One catch from Shopify's docs: customers have to add all the items to the cart themselves. The free item isn't added automatically, so your email and landing page need to say exactly what to add.
A few rules I'd follow:
- Build the bundle around the hero product. Hero plus the thing that makes sense next, the same logic as the cross-sell.
- Link straight to the bundle or a page that matches the email. If the email says one price and the page shows another, people leave.
- Watch the discount size. A bigger cart at a deep discount can leave you with a higher AOV and less profit. Track both. My take on when offers help and when they hurt is in email discount strategy.
- Use loyalty thresholds as a nudge. If you run a loyalty program, remind customers of the actual value of their points with threshold-triggered emails, not only inside the reorder email. Shopify lists loyalty programs with spending thresholds as an AOV tactic too. More in loyalty and referral emails.
How do I know if email is raising my AOV?
Pick one change at a time and compare. Say you add a second-flavor line to the reorder reminder. Compare the average order value of orders from that flow for the 30 days before and the 30 days after, and check that the number of orders didn't drop. A higher AOV on fewer orders isn't a win.
For tests inside campaigns, judge the result on the right metric. An offer test is judged on revenue, not opens or clicks. If you're testing a free shipping threshold against a percent off, revenue and profit per order tell you who won. My Klaviyo A/B testing post covers how long to run it.
FAQ
What is a good way to increase average order value with email?
Add a second product where people are already buying. A "add a second flavor to this order" line in the reorder reminder and a per-product cross-sell flow are the two I'd start with.
Do free shipping thresholds increase average order value?
They give people a reason to add more to the cart, and Shopify recommends them. Set the threshold from your real shipping cost and margin, then test it. Shopify notes results vary by product, customer base, shipping cost and threshold.
Should every email include an upsell?
No. Accessories should wait until the customer has used the main product, and restock products shouldn't ask for another purchase too soon. Pushing a bigger order in every email trains people to ignore you.
Are dynamic product recommendation blocks better than per-product flows?
My default is per-product flows, because a clear pick written for that exact pair says why the second product fits. A general cross-sell flow is a good way to learn which products people reach for next.
How do I calculate average order value?
Total revenue divided by number of orders. Shopify's reports use gross sales minus discounts divided by orders, excluding taxes, shipping and returns.
- Average Order Value (AOV): Formula & Tips, Shopify
- Free Shipping: 8 Strategies To Boost Sales, Shopify
- Free shipping discounts, Shopify Help Center
- Buy X get Y discounts, Shopify Help Center
- Shopify Bundles, Shopify Help Center
- How to show or hide template blocks and sections based on dynamic variables, Klaviyo Help Center
- How to add a trigger split to a flow, Klaviyo Help Center