STRATEGY

How to grow your SMS list without burning it

To grow your SMS list, ask for phone numbers in the places people already raise their hand: a two-step popup (email first, phone second), the SMS checkbox at Shopify checkout, and a text-to-join keyword. Keep double opt-in on, put clear disclosure next to every ask, and give new subscribers texts worth getting so they don't reply STOP in week one. This is for Shopify founders on Klaviyo who want more SMS subscribers without filling the list with people who never really wanted texts.

Jack White
Jack White Founder, Bardown Digital
Updated · 10 min read
KEY TAKEAWAYS
  • Use a two-step signup form. Klaviyo calls multi-step forms "the best option for collecting both email and SMS consent."
  • Turn on the SMS checkbox at Shopify checkout and sync it to Klaviyo. Consent syncs even if the shopper never finishes the order.
  • Keep double opt-in on for SMS. I use single opt-in for email, but SMS is a different channel and commitment to the list matters.
  • Add disclosure language everywhere you ask for a number, above the button or checkbox.
  • Growth only counts if people stay. Your first texts should be your highest-leverage marketing.

What does "burning" an SMS list mean?

It means growing the list in a way that makes it worth less. Phone numbers from people who didn't clearly agree to texts. Subscribers who signed up for a code and opt out the moment they get it. A list so blasted in the first month that the people left aren't listening.

A bigger list is only good if the people on it want to hear from you. So the goal isn't the most phone numbers. It's the most phone numbers from people who asked.

Why should you grow your SMS list differently from your email list?

Because SMS is a more acute form of marketing. It's timely and urgent, it shows up on someone's lock screen, and it does very little for brand awareness on its own. That's why I want people to actively commit to being on the SMS list.

For email, I do the opposite. I always set email lists to single opt-in, because someone who came in from a cold ad and typed their email shouldn't hit extra steps on the way to a first order. I explain that in Klaviyo double opt-in. The email side of list growth has its own playbook, covered in how to grow your email list.

The way I think about the two channels: texts are reminders, emails are branding and awareness. You grow the email list wide. You grow the SMS list with people who want the reminders.

Where do new SMS subscribers come from?

Klaviyo groups its opt-in methods into basic, intermediate and advanced, and suggests adding the intermediate ones after your core setup and key SMS flows are live. Here they are for a Shopify brand, roughly in that order.

1. A two-step popup: email first, then phone

Start here. Klaviyo's guidance is to use "a multi-step popup that collects an email address on the first step, followed by a phone number on the second step."

Why two steps? Each channel gets its own consent, and the phone field doesn't get in the way of the email signup. Klaviyo only recommends a single-step form for both "with double opt-in and when SMS consent is clearly optional," and it warns that putting both on the same step can make people think SMS is required.

Two settings worth knowing in Klaviyo forms:

  • Smart Opt-in. The visitor enters a phone number, Klaviyo texts them a one-time code, and they enter the code on the next step (phones can autofill it). Klaviyo calls it the optimized method for list growth. It needs a paid SMS plan and can't be used on age-gated forms.
  • Tap-to-text. The visitor taps a button and sends a pre-written text. Klaviyo says single opt-in can work here because the visitor already takes two actions. It isn't available if you send from a branded sender ID.

To get more people through the first step of the popup at all, see signup form conversion rate.

2. The SMS checkbox at Shopify checkout

Checkout is the other place people raise their hand, and it's easy to miss. In Shopify, go to Settings, then Checkout, and turn on SMS under marketing options. In Klaviyo, go to Integrations, then Shopify, then Sync settings, and on the From Shopify tab check the box to sync your Shopify text message subscribers to a list.

Two details from Klaviyo's help center:

  • Consent syncs once the shopper enters a phone number, checks the box and clicks "Continue to shipping." They don't have to finish the order.
  • It only syncs people subscribing to SMS in Shopify for the first time. Older subscribers need a separate process.

Shopify Plus brands can also use SMS app blocks on checkout pages, which Klaviyo says can collect consent on the thank you and order status pages too.

3. Text-to-join keywords

A keyword lets someone text a word like JOIN to your number to subscribe. It's the method for anywhere a form can't go: packaging inserts, events, retail shelves, social bios, business cards.

In Klaviyo you set these up under Settings, then Text message, then Keyword responses. A few rules from Klaviyo:

  • Double opt-in is the default and "highly recommended for subscribe keywords." Klaviyo advises against publishing single opt-in keywords on your website.
  • Keywords are 3 to 20 characters, letters and numbers only, and you can have up to 500.
  • You can't use keywords from a branded sender ID, because it can't receive replies.
  • You still need disclosure language anywhere you show the keyword.

4. Your email list

Klaviyo lists email as an intermediate method: link to a page with an embedded SMS form, add a click-to-text banner, or include an SMS subscribe link. Note that click-to-text banners only work on mobile and not in Gmail or Outlook.

This one fits how I use the channels anyway. Your email subscribers already know you. Asking the engaged ones to also get texts for restocks, launches and deadlines is an easy pitch.

5. Subscribe links in social and ads

Klaviyo's subscribe links can go in ads and social posts, and Instagram stickers are an option if you're already active there. Like email, Klaviyo files these under methods to add once the basics are running.

What should you offer in exchange for a phone number?

Give people a clear reason. Postscript's advice is to trigger popups after real engagement (it suggests 15 to 30 seconds on site), make the benefit clear and test incentives against each other. It also points out that non-discount offers like VIP or early access can lift signups without cutting margin.

If your popup leads with a discount, consider testing cash back instead. Brands offering cash back on the signup popup instead of a discount see 10 to 20% higher first-order profit, because the non-customer places that first order without a discount. More on that trade-off in email popup discount.

Whatever the offer is, don't make SMS the price of it. Klaviyo says consent can't be forced. A shopper should be able to get the email offer without handing over a phone number.

Does double opt-in slow down SMS list growth?

A little, at first. Postscript says double opt-in may produce "slightly fewer subscribers initially." I'm fine with that trade.

Here's why. Klaviyo says double opt-in "is always recommended" for SMS, and in the US it's a carrier requirement if you want to send abandoned cart texts. So if you skip it, you may grow faster on paper and then find you can't send abandoned cart texts at all. More on that flow in abandoned cart SMS.

The second reason is the one I care about most. The people who confirm are the people who wanted to be there. On a channel this direct, that's the list you want.

What do you have to show people when they sign up?

Disclosure, every time. Klaviyo says disclosure language is required wherever you collect SMS consent: forms, checkout, email banners, social posts, keywords and third-party tools. Put it "above the SMS consent checkbox or button" so people see it before they opt in, and keep it on both desktop and mobile views. It should include your brand name and links to your mobile terms and privacy policy.

Klaviyo also says a general "agree to marketing" checkbox isn't enough for SMS in most countries. SMS consent needs its own ask.

In the US, the law underneath this is the TCPA. The FCC's rules require "prior express written consent" before telemarketing robocalls, which covers calls made with an autodialer. Postscript also recommends keeping opt-in records, including the disclosure text people saw, for at least four years. The full setup, with sample disclosure language, is in SMS marketing consent on Shopify.

This is general information, not legal advice.

What should you text new subscribers so they stay?

A new SMS list is easy to burn in the first week. Someone just gave you their number. Make the first texts count.

If you just turned on SMS, send the highest-leverage marketing possible and see what works: a bestseller, a restock, a launch, a real offer. Not a brand story. Save that for email.

In automations, my habit is to include an offer by the second text. And remember the job of the channel: texts are reminders. One of the best uses of a text is to remind people to read the email you already sent.

Build this into a proper welcome flow so every new subscriber gets the same good start. I walk through one in SMS welcome series, and how often to text after that is in how often to send SMS.

What should you check first?

  1. Your popup: is SMS on its own second step, optional, with disclosure above the button?
  2. Your SMS list: is double opt-in on?
  3. Shopify checkout: is the SMS box on and syncing into an SMS list in Klaviyo?
  4. Keywords: do you have one set up, and is it printed anywhere a form can't reach?
  5. Your first texts: is your welcome flow live before you start growing?

FAQ

What's the fastest way to grow an SMS list on Shopify?

A two-step popup that asks for email first and phone second, plus the SMS checkbox at checkout. Klaviyo calls multi-step forms the best option for collecting both email and SMS consent.

Can I add customers' phone numbers from past orders to my SMS list?

Not unless they agreed to marketing texts. A phone number on an order isn't SMS consent, and Klaviyo says a general marketing checkbox isn't enough for SMS in most countries.

Should I use single or double opt-in for SMS?

Double. Klaviyo recommends it and says it's a US carrier requirement for abandoned cart texts. I use single opt-in for email and double for SMS.

Do text-to-join keywords need double opt-in?

In Klaviyo, double opt-in is the default for subscribe keywords and is highly recommended. Klaviyo only recommends single opt-in for tap-to-text.

Does Shopify checkout consent count if the customer doesn't buy?

Yes. Klaviyo says consent syncs once the shopper checks the box and clicks "Continue to shipping," even if they never complete the order.

Jack White, founder of Bardown Digital
WRITTEN BY Jack White

Founder of Bardown Digital, a Chicago-based Klaviyo email and retention agency for Shopify brands. He's worked with brands doing $500K to $100M a year, with $100M+ in email-attributed revenue across them.

SOURCES

Keep reading

All posts →
STRATEGY · 10 MIN READ

How to raise average order value with email

Raise average order value with email: second products in the reorder reminder, per-product cross-sells, free shipping thresholds and bundles, timed right.

Read the post →
STRATEGY · 10 MIN READ

Klaviyo RFM segmentation: recency, frequency and money, explained

How Klaviyo's RFM analysis scores customers, the six groups it uses, what plan you need, and how to build RFM-style segments yourself without it.

Read the post →
STRATEGY · 10 MIN READ

Klaviyo signup form not showing on Shopify? How to fix it

Klaviyo signup form not showing? Check that it's Live, the Klaviyo app embed is on in your Shopify theme, then targeting, timing and frequency rules.

Read the post →

Get a second opinion on your SMS list growth

If your SMS list is growing slowly, or growing fast and opting out just as fast, it's worth a look at your forms, checkout settings and first few texts. The first strategy session is free: one hour, live with me in your Klaviyo account, and you leave with a fix list whether we work together or not. Not ready to book? Grab one of my free resources instead.

Book a strategy session
Or email me at jackwhite@bardowndigital.com