METRICS & DELIVERABILITY

Email list growth rate: how to calculate it and what good looks like

Your email list growth rate is the number of new subscribers you added in a period, minus everyone you lost (unsubscribes, hard bounces, spam complaints), divided by the size of your list at the start of that period. Multiply by 100 and you have a percentage you can track month to month. There's no published universal benchmark for what "good" is, so the most useful target is your own baseline, and I'll show you how to set one.

Jack White
Jack White Founder, Bardown Digital
Updated · 9 min read
KEY TAKEAWAYS
  • The formula: (new subscribers minus unsubscribes and other losses) ÷ starting list size × 100.
  • I couldn't find a credible, ecommerce-specific benchmark for list growth rate from Klaviyo or another reputable source. Anyone quoting one universal number is guessing.
  • Klaviyo gives you two places to pull the inputs: a list's Growth report and the subscriber growth report. They count different things, so pick one and stick with it.
  • A growth rate only matters if new subscribers buy. Track it next to welcome email revenue, not on its own.
  • Don't try to fix a weak growth rate by cleaning harder. Fix capture.

This is for Shopify founders on Klaviyo who want one number that says whether the list is actually growing, not just getting bigger on paper.

How do you calculate email list growth rate?

Here's the formula:

List growth rate = (new subscribers − unsubscribes and other losses) ÷ starting list size × 100

"Other losses" means anyone who dropped off the list for a reason besides clicking unsubscribe: hard bounces, spam complaints, and anyone you removed by hand.

HubSpot's version of the formula divides by the total number of addresses on your list instead of the starting size. Either works. Dividing by the starting size is cleaner, because the denominator doesn't move while you're still counting new signups. Whichever you pick, use the same one every month or your trend line means nothing.

A worked example (hypothetical)

These numbers are made up to show the math. They aren't from a client account.

Say your list has 10,000 subscribers on October 1. During October:

  • 600 people subscribe
  • 150 unsubscribe
  • 40 hard bounce
  • 10 mark an email as spam

Your losses are 150 + 40 + 10 = 200. Your net gain is 600 − 200 = 400.

400 ÷ 10,000 = 0.04, so your October list growth rate is 4%.

Now say November brings 900 new subscribers but 500 losses, because you sent a lot more during Black Friday. Your starting list is 10,400. Net gain is 400 again, and 400 ÷ 10,400 is about 3.8%. Same net number, very different month. That's why I'd always look at gains and losses separately, not just the final percentage.

What is a good email list growth rate?

The short answer: there isn't one number. I looked for a benchmark I'd stand behind and didn't find one.

  • Klaviyo's help center articles on list growth and subscriber growth reporting explain how the reports work, but neither publishes a benchmark.
  • Klaviyo's own blog post introducing the subscriber growth report talks about comparing your current subscriber count to prior periods. No benchmark there either.
  • HubSpot's guide to email metrics explains the formula and gives a worked example, but no benchmark for growth rate itself.

What you will find are figures on how fast lists shrink. HubSpot's metrics guide cites ZeroBounce data that a list "expires by about 28% every year." HubSpot's database decay page uses about 22.5% a year, based on MarketingSherpa research on B2B data, and Shopify's blog on list hygiene cites HubSpot for "about 22%." None of those are ecommerce-specific, and two of them trace back to B2B data or a list-cleaning vendor. I'd treat them as a reminder that lists leak, not as a target.

The point stands, though. If you aren't adding people, your list is shrinking, even if you never look.

How do you set your own baseline?

This is what I'd do instead of chasing someone else's number.

  1. Pull the last 6 to 12 months. Use the same Klaviyo report each time (more on which one below). Monthly is the right view for this. Weekly is too noisy.
  2. Write down three numbers per month. New subscribers, total losses, and your growth rate. Keep gains and losses side by side.
  3. Mark the unusual months. BFCM, a big launch, a paid traffic push, a month you barely emailed. Those months will skew the average.
  4. Find your normal range. Take your typical months, not your best one. That's your baseline.
  5. Set a target off your own trend. If your normal month lands between 2 and 3%, aim to push the bottom of that range up. Don't jump to a number you read on a forum.

Then check it alongside the things that drive it. Your popup is the biggest lever for most Shopify brands, so watch your form's submit rate too. My breakdown of what Klaviyo considers a good number is in signup form conversion rate.

Where do you find list growth in Klaviyo?

Klaviyo has two reports, and they don't measure the same thing.

A list's Growth report. Go to Audience, then Lists & segments, open the list, and click Growth. Klaviyo says the top number "shows members gained minus members lost during this period." It breaks additions down by source (sign-up forms, API, list import, back in stock) and removals by method (hard bounce, spam complaint, one-click unsubscribe, manually removed, merged profiles). Klaviyo is clear that this tracks list membership, which isn't the same as marketing consent.

The subscriber growth report. Go to Audience, then Profiles, and click View subscriber growth. This one tracks profiles with explicit marketing consent, per channel (email, text message and WhatsApp). It shows new subscribers, excluded subscribers, top opt-in sources and exclusion reasons like unsubscribe, hard bounce and spam complaint. Klaviyo notes a profile that subscribes and unsubscribes on the same day isn't counted as new.

If you build your own reports, the matching metrics in Klaviyo are Subscribed to List ("when someone opts in to a list") and Unsubscribed from List ("when someone unsubscribes from a specific list"). There's also Subscribed to Email Marketing and Unsubscribed from Email Marketing for consent changes.

My pick: use your main list's Growth report for the formula above. It gives you starting size, gains and losses in one place, and you can export it to CSV. Both reports can lag by up to 3 hours, so don't panic over today's number.

Why is my email list growth rate low?

Usually it's one of these.

Your capture is weak. The popup fires too early, the offer isn't clear, or the mobile version is broken. That's where most of the fix lives. My full playbook is in how to grow your email list.

Your list is on double opt-in. Klaviyo says "only subscribers who confirm their subscription will be successfully added to the list." Everyone who fills out the form but never clicks the confirmation email doesn't count toward your growth at all. I use single opt-in for email. A non-customer coming off a cold ad and heading into the welcome series shouldn't hit extra steps that might stop an order. If someone typed in their email, they want to be on the list. More in Klaviyo double opt-in.

Your losses are high. If gains look fine but net growth is flat, look at the removals side of the report. Lots of unsubscribes points at what or how often you're sending. Lots of hard bounces points at where the bad addresses are coming from. My take on unsubscribes is in what's a good unsubscribe rate.

You're cleaning instead of capturing. Aside from removing obviously bad profiles, founders obsess too much over cleaning the list instead of adding better profiles and systems to capture them. Cleaning makes your growth rate look worse in the month you do it, and it doesn't bring anyone new in. Remove the junk, set up a sunset flow so it stays manageable, and put your energy into capture. If you need the cleanup steps, they're in email list cleaning.

Does a higher list growth rate mean more revenue?

Not on its own. You can double your growth rate with a bigger popup discount and add nothing if those people never buy.

The money from a new subscriber shows up early. Across 4 consumable brands I pulled data on, welcome email #1 earned about $4.50 per person, while emails #2 to #5 earned about $0.10 each. If your list is growing but that first email is weak, fix the email before you buy more signups.

The offer matters too. Brands offering cash back on the signup popup instead of a discount see 10-20% higher first-order profit, because non-customers place a first order without a discount. Same growth, better margin. I go deeper on this in should your email popup offer a discount.

And bigger isn't automatically better for campaigns. A sports training tech brand I work with earned $0.19 per person from an engaged send to 7,145 people, versus $0.04 per person from a blast to 49,475. If you're wondering how big your list needs to be in the first place, read how big should your email list be.

If you're hitting your Klaviyo plan limit because the list is growing, upgrade. Focus on making more money from Klaviyo, not saving money on it.

Where these numbers come from

The welcome email numbers are pooled from 4 consumable brands I work with. It's a small sample, so read it as directional. The engaged-send numbers and the cash back figure come from client accounts. The October and November example above is hypothetical.

FAQ

What is the formula for email list growth rate?

New subscribers minus unsubscribes and other losses (hard bounces, spam complaints, manual removals), divided by your list size at the start of the period, times 100.

What's a good monthly email list growth rate?

There's no reliable universal benchmark from Klaviyo or another reputable source. Set a baseline from your own last 6 to 12 months and work to raise your typical month.

Should I count hard bounces and spam complaints as losses?

Yes. They're off your list either way. Klaviyo's list Growth report includes both in its removals.

Where can I see list growth in Klaviyo?

Open the list under Audience, then Lists & segments, and click Growth. For consent-based numbers by channel, go to Audience, then Profiles, and click View subscriber growth.

Does double opt-in lower my list growth rate?

It can. Klaviyo only adds people to a double opt-in list after they confirm, so anyone who doesn't click the confirmation email never counts.

Jack White, founder of Bardown Digital
WRITTEN BY Jack White

Founder of Bardown Digital, a Chicago-based Klaviyo email and retention agency for Shopify brands. He's worked with brands doing $500K to $100M a year, with $100M+ in email-attributed revenue across them.

SOURCES

Keep reading

All posts →
METRICS & DELIVERABILITY · 10 MIN READ

Email marketing KPIs for Shopify brands: the five worth watching

The five email marketing KPIs a Shopify founder should watch: revenue per recipient, click rate, placed order rate, email share of revenue and list health.

Read the post →
METRICS & DELIVERABILITY · 10 MIN READ

Klaviyo emails going to spam? How I'd find the cause

Klaviyo emails going to spam? How to check if you're landing in spam, then fix authentication, list hygiene, unengaged sends and Gmail and Yahoo rules.

Read the post →
METRICS & DELIVERABILITY · 8 MIN READ

How to clean your email list in Klaviyo (and when to stop cleaning)

How to clean your email list in Klaviyo: which profiles to suppress, the segments to build, suppress vs delete, and why cleaning isn't the growth plan.

Read the post →

Want me to look at your list growth?

A growth rate is only useful if you know which sources bring in buyers and which ones just add to your bill. The first strategy session is free: one hour, live with me in your Klaviyo account, and you leave with a fix list even if we never work together. Not ready to book? Grab one of my free resources instead.

Book a strategy session
Or email me at jackwhite@bardowndigital.com