METRICS & DELIVERABILITY

Klaviyo benchmarks: how to read the peer comparison without fooling yourself

Klaviyo benchmarks compare your email, SMS, flow and signup form results to a peer group of roughly 100 similar companies, and label each metric Poor, Fair, Good or Excellent. You find them under Analytics, then Benchmarks. They're useful for spotting where you're clearly behind, as long as you read them the right way: trust click rate, conversion rate and revenue per recipient, be skeptical of open rate, and check that Klaviyo has your industry set correctly. This post is for Shopify founders who opened the Benchmarks page, saw a mix of green and red, and want to know what to do with it.

Jack White
Jack White Founder, Bardown Digital
Updated · 7 min read
KEY TAKEAWAYS
  • Peer groups are about 100 companies matched on industry, size and how they send. Set your industry correctly first.
  • "Good" means you're between the 50th and 75th percentile of your peers. It's a comparison, not a target.
  • Open rate benchmarks are inflated by Apple Mail Privacy Protection. Lean on clicks and revenue per recipient.
  • Across 4 consumable brands, click rate tracked revenue at 0.65 versus 0.32 for open rate.
  • Use benchmarks to pick what to test, then judge the test on your own numbers.

Where are benchmarks in Klaviyo?

In Klaviyo, go to Analytics > Benchmarks. Klaviyo's guide lists five pages:

  • Overview: your top and bottom performing metrics at a glance.
  • Business performance: average order value, average cart size, average order count and the share of orders returned.
  • Campaigns: email and SMS campaign metrics.
  • Flows: the same metrics for flows, split by email and SMS.
  • Sign-up forms: form submit rates.

A few rules from Klaviyo's help center. Benchmarks are available for US data region accounts. You need at least 25 delivered emails in the last 6 months for email peer benchmarks, and 25 delivered texts for SMS. And benchmarks update with new data on the 10th of every month, so checking them daily won't tell you anything new.

How does Klaviyo pick my peer group?

Automatically. Klaviyo says peer groups are a set of roughly 100 companies similar to yours in industry, size and scope, such as average item value, total revenue and year-over-year growth, and in campaign habits, such as how often you send and what share of revenue comes from email.

The one thing you control is your industry. It's set in your organization settings, and you can change it from the benchmarks page with Change industry. Klaviyo lets you change it 2 times every 30 days. If you sell snacks and Klaviyo thinks you're in apparel, every comparison on the page is off. Check this first.

Email is compared to your peer group. SMS is compared to your industry, which is a broader group. Klaviyo's column labels say which: "Median (Peers)" or "Median (Industry)."

What do Poor, Fair, Good and Excellent mean?

Klaviyo's guide ties the labels to percentiles within your peer group, roughly:

  • Poor: below the 25th percentile
  • Fair: 25th to 50th
  • Good: 50th to 75th
  • Excellent: above the 75th

Klaviyo's detailed view also shows your exact percentile and the 25th percentile, median and 75th percentile values. If you're at the 75th percentile, you did better than 75% of that group.

Two things worth knowing about how Klaviyo calculates them. First, rates are pooled, not averaged. Klaviyo's example: one send with 25 clicks out of 50 and another with 20 out of 100 is 45 out of 150, or 30%, not the 35% you'd get averaging the two rates. Your big sends count more than your small ones. Second, "Good" only means better than half of about 100 similar brands. If your peers are weak at something, Good can still be leaving money on the table.

Which Klaviyo benchmarks should I trust?

Not all of them equally.

Open rate: be skeptical. Klaviyo's own benchmarks guide says open rates "will be inflated" because of Apple Mail Privacy Protection. Apple auto-opens push some segments past 85%. So a Good or Excellent open rate can mean your list is heavy on Apple Mail users, not that people are reading.

Click rate: trust it more. Across 4 consumable brands and 2,897 campaigns, click rate had a 0.65 correlation with revenue, versus 0.32 for open rate. For one of those brands, open rate was negatively related to revenue. I go deeper on this in open rate vs click rate and what's a good click rate for email.

Conversion rate and revenue per recipient: the ones that pay. These tell you whether email turns into orders. If clicks are Good and conversion is Poor, the problem is probably after the click: the landing page, the offer, or the product. More on conversion in email conversion rate benchmarks.

Spam report, bounce and unsubscribe rates: read them as warnings. These are the deliverability numbers. Poor here deserves attention before anything else, because it affects whether the rest of your email lands at all.

How do I read flow benchmarks?

Flow benchmarks are where I'd spend the most time, because flows are steady and they compare like with like better than campaigns do.

But they're a flow-level average. A welcome flow can look Fair overall while email #1 is doing almost all the work. Across 4 brands, welcome email #1 earns $4.50 per person and emails #2 to #5 about $0.10 each. Open the flow itself and compare email by email before you change anything. I walk through that in Klaviyo flow performance.

Also check what's missing. Benchmarks only compare the flows you have. Across 4 brands, replenishment flows earned $2.23 per person, about 28x the best campaign, and only 2 of the 4 had one. No benchmark will tell you to build a flow you don't have.

How do I turn a benchmark into an action?

Use it to pick the test, not to declare a winner. Then match the test to the metric:

  • Poor open rate? Test subject lines, judged on opens.
  • Poor click rate? Test content and calls to action, judged on clicks.
  • Poor conversion or revenue? Test the offer, judged on revenue.
  • Poor revenue per recipient across the board? Test who you send to, judged on revenue per recipient. A sports training tech brand's engaged send to 7,145 people earned $0.19 per person, versus $0.04 per person for a blast to 49,475.

Repeat a test across about five campaign sends, consistently, at normal send sizes, before treating it as a rule. Benchmarks update monthly, so they're a good place to check whether the change held. My testing setup is in Klaviyo A/B testing.

Should I compare myself to published industry benchmarks too?

Sure, as a second opinion. Klaviyo's peer benchmarks are closer to your situation than a general industry report. Outside benchmark reports are often a year or more old and mix very different brands, so read the date and who's in the sample. My roundup for consumable brands is in CPG email marketing benchmarks.

The best benchmark is still your own trend. Are clicks, conversions and revenue per recipient up versus last quarter? A once-a-week look at the right numbers beats a once-a-month look at a percentile. Mine is in the weekly Klaviyo check.

FAQ

Where do I find benchmarks in Klaviyo?

Analytics, then Benchmarks. There are pages for overview, business performance, campaigns, flows and signup forms.

How often do Klaviyo benchmarks update?

Klaviyo says on the 10th of every month.

Why don't I see benchmarks in Klaviyo?

You need a US data region account, at least 25 delivered emails in the last 6 months for email benchmarks, and an industry set on your account.

Can I change my Klaviyo peer group?

Not directly. Klaviyo assigns it. You can change your industry, up to 2 times every 30 days, which changes who you're compared to.

Is a "Good" Klaviyo benchmark good enough?

It means you're between the 50th and 75th percentile of about 100 similar companies. It's a reasonable floor, not a goal. Look at revenue per recipient and your own trend before deciding.

Jack White, founder of Bardown Digital
WRITTEN BY Jack White

Founder of Bardown Digital, a Chicago-based Klaviyo email and retention agency for Shopify brands. He's worked with brands doing $500K to $100M a year, with $100M+ in email-attributed revenue across them.

SOURCES

Keep reading

All posts →
METRICS & DELIVERABILITY · 8 MIN READ

How to clean your email list in Klaviyo (and when to stop cleaning)

How to clean your email list in Klaviyo: which profiles to suppress, the segments to build, suppress vs delete, and why cleaning isn't the growth plan.

Read the post →
METRICS & DELIVERABILITY · 8 MIN READ

Google Postmaster Tools for Shopify brands: what to check and what it means

How to set up Google Postmaster Tools for your Klaviyo sending domain, which dashboards to check, what the spam rate means, and what to do when it's high.

Read the post →
METRICS & DELIVERABILITY · 9 MIN READ

Klaviyo DMARC and branded sending domain: step by step

How to set up a branded sending domain and DMARC record in Klaviyo, step by step: the DNS records, which policy to start on, and when to tighten it.

Read the post →

Want help reading your benchmarks?

The page is easy to misread, especially the open rates. The first strategy session is free: one hour, live with me in your Klaviyo account, and you leave with a fix list even if we never work together. Not ready to book? Grab one of my free resources instead.

Book a strategy session
Or email me at jackwhite@bardowndigital.com