METRICS & DELIVERABILITY

How to read Klaviyo flow performance, email by email

To read Klaviyo flow performance properly, look at each email in the flow, not the flow total. Open the flow, turn on Show Analytics, and compare revenue per recipient and click rate message by message. The flow total tells you whether a flow makes money. The email-by-email view tells you where it's leaking and what to fix. This post is for Shopify founders who can see their flows earning something in Klaviyo but can't tell which emails are doing the work.

Jack White
Jack White Founder, Bardown Digital
Updated · 7 min read
KEY TAKEAWAYS
  • Judge each flow email on revenue per recipient and click rate. Open rates are inflated by Apple Mail Privacy Protection.
  • Different flows have different shapes. Welcome is front-loaded, winback builds, and cart flows keep earning late.
  • Across 4 brands, welcome email #1 earns $4.50 per person and emails #2 to #5 about $0.10 each.
  • Across 4 brands, winback email #3 earns about 2x email #1, and cart email #5 earns the same as #3.
  • Export flow analytics to CSV to see every email in every flow on one sheet.

Where do I see flow performance in Klaviyo?

There are three places, and each answers a different question.

1. Inside the flow (email by email). Open any flow and click Show Analytics in the header bar. Each message card shows its open rate, click rate, conversion rate and conversion value. You can change the time range, including custom dates. This is where you spot the weak email.

2. The flow analytics dashboard (all flows). This tracks revenue, conversions, conversion rate, deliveries and unique recipients across your flows. The default range is the last 7 days, and you can pick 30 days, 90 days, 12 months, or a custom range up to 366 days. It compares flows to each other, but it doesn't break them down by message.

3. A flows performance report or export (everything on one sheet). In Klaviyo's custom reports, a flows performance report can group data by individual flow message and show A/B variations separately. You can export it to CSV. Or, from the Flows tab, click Options, then Export analytics, for a CSV with one row per message.

The export is what I'd use for a real review. You can sort every email in the account by revenue per recipient and by volume in one view. The export also shows where volume is, which is where tests pay off fastest.

Which metric should I trust?

Revenue per recipient first, click rate second, open rate last.

Klaviyo's own help center says Apple Mail Privacy Protection "artificially inflates your open rates and makes it harder to identify subscribers who are truly engaged." So an email with a great open rate might not be getting read at all.

Clicks are a better signal. Across 4 consumable brands and 2,897 campaigns, click rate had a 0.65 correlation with revenue, versus 0.32 for open rate. For one brand, open rate was negatively correlated with revenue.

Revenue per recipient puts every email on the same scale, whether it went to 50 people or 50,000. If you want the math, see revenue per recipient. For more on opens versus clicks, see open rate vs click rate.

How does Klaviyo decide which flow email gets the credit?

By attribution. For new accounts, Klaviyo's default is last touch: 100% of the credit goes to the last eligible email or text before the order, within the attribution window. The default window is 5 days for email opens and 5 days for email clicks. Klaviyo removes Apple Privacy Protection opens from attribution, but not from reporting.

Two things follow from that:

  • Emails late in a flow can look stronger than they are. They're often the last touch before an order that earlier emails set up.
  • Changing attribution settings changes history. Klaviyo recalculates past data when the settings change. Agree on the settings before you compare months. More in Klaviyo attribution.

What should each flow look like, email by email?

Every flow has a shape. Once you know the normal shape, the broken email jumps out.

Flow Normal shape What it looked like across 4 brands
Welcome Front-loaded: email #1 does most of the work Email #1 earns $4.50 per person, #2 to #5 about $0.10 each (30x)
Abandoned cart Keeps earning late Email #5 still earns $0.25 per person, the same as #3
Winback Builds: later emails can beat the first Email #3 earns about 2x email #1 ($0.23 vs $0.11)

Welcome. If email #1 isn't your best email by a wide margin, something is off with the offer or the timing. A sleep wellness brand's welcome email #1 made $2,160 from 50 deliveries in May.

Cart. If revenue drops to near zero after email #2, don't assume people stopped caring. Check the copy and the offer in the later emails before you cut them. Keep cart flows long.

Winback. Don't judge a winback flow by email #1. People who've gone quiet often need a few touches. More in how long should a winback flow be.

What's a red flag in flow performance?

Look for these when you go email by email:

  • Clicks but no revenue. A strength training gear brand's restock email hit a 0.40% click rate, double its other sends, and made $0. About 20 sends in the same account showed opens and revenue but zero clicks. Both were tracking problems, not copy problems. See email clicks but no sales.
  • Deliveries far below what you'd expect. Smart Sending may be skipping people. I keep it off on automations so people don't miss critical reminders. A haircare brand's abandoned checkout emails had it on, and many people never got their reminders.
  • A flow that stopped. If deliveries drop to zero, check the trigger and filters. See Klaviyo flow not sending.
  • One flow carrying everything. Healthy accounts have several flows earning. If one does all the work, the others probably need depth.

What should I test first?

Subject lines. Start in campaigns or automations, wherever the flow export shows the most volume. Send at least 100 emails per version before you decide.

Test the emails with the most volume and the weakest revenue per recipient. Those are your leaks. Klaviyo lets you A/B test flow emails directly, and I walk through that in Klaviyo A/B testing.

If you use Klaviyo's Composer, it's worth asking where it thinks the leaks are in your customer attention. Once or twice a month is plenty. I compared it to doing it yourself in Klaviyo Composer review.

How often should I review flow performance?

Monthly for a full email-by-email pass, using at least 30 days of data so small flows have enough volume. Glance at the flow dashboard weekly for anything that dropped to zero. A simple weekly routine is in weekly Klaviyo check, and the deeper version is the Klaviyo audit checklist.

If your flows look fine but total revenue isn't moving, see Klaviyo revenue flat.

FAQ

How do I see the performance of each email in a Klaviyo flow?

Open the flow and click Show Analytics in the header bar. Each message shows open rate, click rate, conversion rate and conversion value for the time range you pick.

Can I export Klaviyo flow performance?

Yes. From the Flows tab, click Options, then Export analytics, for a CSV with a row per message. Or build a flows performance report grouped by flow message and export it.

What is a good flow performance in Klaviyo?

Compare each email to its flow's normal shape. Across 4 brands, welcome email #1 earned $4.50 per person, cart email #5 $0.25 and winback email #3 $0.23.

Why is my flow open rate so high but revenue low?

Apple Mail Privacy Protection inflates opens. Judge flow emails on clicks and revenue per recipient instead.

What attribution window does Klaviyo use for flows?

The default for new accounts is 5 days for email opens and 5 days for email clicks, last touch. Check your own account's settings.

Jack White, founder of Bardown Digital
WRITTEN BY Jack White

Founder of Bardown Digital, a Chicago-based Klaviyo email and retention agency for Shopify brands. He's worked with brands doing $500K to $100M a year, with $100M+ in email-attributed revenue across them.

SOURCES

Keep reading

All posts →
METRICS & DELIVERABILITY · 7 MIN READ

BIMI for Shopify brands: is the logo in the inbox worth it?

What BIMI email is, what it takes to get your logo next to your emails in Gmail and Yahoo, what it costs, and when a Shopify brand should bother.

Read the post →
METRICS & DELIVERABILITY · 8 MIN READ

Klaviyo bounce rate: hard vs soft bounces and what's too high

What a good Klaviyo bounce rate is, how hard and soft bounces differ, when Klaviyo suppresses a profile, and how to fix a high bounce rate at the source.

Read the post →
METRICS & DELIVERABILITY · 7 MIN READ

Klaviyo UTM tracking: set it up so Shopify and GA4 agree

How to set up Klaviyo UTM tracking for campaigns and flows, which parameters to use, and why Klaviyo, Shopify and GA4 still won't show the same revenue.

Read the post →

Want a second set of eyes on your flows?

I'll go through them email by email with you. The first strategy session is free: one hour, live with me in your Klaviyo account, and you leave with a fix list even if we never work together. Not ready to book? Grab one of my free resources instead.

Book a strategy session
Or email me at jackwhite@bardowndigital.com