BY BRAND TYPE

Email marketing for sleep brands: educate, then ask

Sleep brand email marketing works when you teach people something about their nights and then ask them to buy, in the same email. Education builds the trust a sleep purchase needs, but on its own it doesn't sell: at a sleep wellness brand, a month of all-educational campaigns took campaign revenue from $3,146 to $110.

Jack White
Jack White Founder, Bardown Digital
Updated · 9 min read
KEY TAKEAWAYS
  • Teach, then ask. Every educational email needs a product and a reason to buy now.
  • Put most of your welcome flow effort into email #1. At a sleep wellness brand it made $2,160 from 50 deliveries in one month.
  • If your product runs out, build a reorder or subscription reminder before you build anything fancy.
  • Sell the product, not a health outcome. Health claims need real evidence, and the FTC judges the whole email, not just the words.
  • Use single opt-in for email so new subscribers actually reach your welcome series.

This is for Shopify founders selling sleep products, whether that's something people use up and reorder or something they buy once and keep for years. If you're on Klaviyo or about to be, this is the order I'd build things in.

Why do sleep brands lean so hard on education?

Because sleep is a considered purchase. People buying for their sleep have usually tried something that didn't work. They read reviews, compare materials or ingredients, and want to know who a product is for before they spend.

So education does real work. It answers the "will this work for me?" question and gives people a reason to trust you. Shopify's guide to health and wellness ecommerce makes the same point, telling brands to "provide detailed information, tutorials, and educational content that help customers make informed choices," and to pair education with subscriptions to make repeat purchases easy.

The trap is that sleep content is easy to make and nice to read. It feels like marketing. Often it's just reading material.

What happens when a sleep brand sends only educational emails?

Revenue disappears. A sleep wellness brand I work with sent all-educational campaigns in May with no offer. Campaign revenue went from $3,146 to $110, down 96.5%.

Content warms people up. Somebody has to ask for the sale.

Here's the shape I'd use for a sleep content email:

  1. Teach one thing. One idea, kept short. "How to set up your room for a cooler night" works.
  2. Connect it to the product. Where does what you sell fit into what you just taught? Plainly, without promising results.
  3. Give a reason to buy now. A new product, a restock, a bundle, a free shipping threshold, early access, or a subscribe perk.
  4. One button. One destination that sells.

You don't need a discount in every email. You need a reason. I go deeper on the balance in content emails vs promotional emails, and the wider wellness version of this is in wellness brand email marketing.

Why does welcome email #1 matter so much for a sleep brand?

Because it's where most of the welcome money is. The same sleep wellness brand's welcome email #1 made $2,160 from 50 deliveries in May. That's about $43 every time it landed in an inbox. Fifty sends is a small sample, so don't treat it as a rate you'll hit. Treat it as proof that one well-built email can carry a considered purchase.

The bigger pattern backs it up. Across 4 brands, welcome email #1 earns $4.50 per person, and emails #2 through #5 earn about $0.10 each. That's 30x. Most brands spread their effort evenly across the series. I'd put most of it into email #1.

Klaviyo's welcome series guide says the first email should introduce new subscribers to your brand, and that if your signup form promises an incentive, it belongs in that first email. For a sleep brand, I'd build email #1 like this:

  • Who it's for, in one line. Hot sleepers, side sleepers, light sleepers, whatever your product is built around.
  • How to choose. If you sell more than one thing, point them to the right first product.
  • Proof that isn't a health claim. Reviews about comfort, materials, how it's made, your trial or return policy.
  • The offer and one button.

One setup check before any of this matters. Klaviyo's guide says double opt-in is the default for your main list. I use single opt-in for email. Someone who just found you through a cold ad and is heading into your welcome series shouldn't have to clear an extra step that may stop the order. More on building the series in my welcome email series guide.

Does a sleep brand sell a consumable or a durable product?

Often both, and the answer changes your flows.

If it runs out (think anything used nightly and reordered), the reorder reminder is your money flow. Across 4 brands, replenishment flows earn $2.23 per person, about 28x the best campaign, and only 2 of the 4 brands had one built. At a subscription wellness brand, the "your order is coming up" reminder made $47,321 in one month, 74% of all its flow revenue. Build it early. My notes on timing are in Klaviyo replenishment flow.

If it lasts for years (bedding, pillows, frames, mattresses), there's no reorder window to time. The next sale is usually a different product: a matching item, an accessory, a gift. That's a different playbook, and I cover it in email marketing for durable goods.

For both, a cross-sell flow helps. Think about what makes sense next in a customer's lifecycle and put it in front of them. Complementary items to your hero product come first. Accessories come later, so you're not hounding someone the week after they bought. For products people restock, don't ask for another purchase too soon.

How should a sleep brand handle subscriptions?

Treat the first 30 days of a new subscriber like onboarding. I build a welcome series for new paying subscribers that helps them get set up and feel looked after, plus easy options to skip, swap or pause instead of canceling. A skipped month beats a cancellation. A health and wellness supplement brand's new-subscriber welcome series increased its repeat rate by more than threefold.

The subscription confirmations themselves come from your subscription app, not Klaviyo. I keep those separate. The series I build is helpful content: how to get set up, what to expect, and what to do if they need to change anything. My full setup is in subscription welcome email.

What can a sleep brand say in its emails?

Less than you'd think. The FTC's Health Products Compliance Guidance says that "the same legal principles apply to the marketing of any health-related product," and that health-related claims require "competent and reliable scientific evidence." A marketer is "equally responsible for the accuracy of claims suggested or reasonably implied," and a testimonial isn't enough just because it reflects someone's honest experience.

For email, that means:

  • Describe the product, not a medical outcome. Materials, how to use it, what's in it, who it's designed for.
  • Watch the implied claims. A subject line, an image and a review quote together can say something you'd never write in a sentence.
  • Run anything about health past a lawyer before it goes in a flow, where it'll send for months.

This is general information, not legal advice.

Which emails should a sleep brand send, and when?

Start with flows, then campaigns. Klaviyo's 2026 benchmarks say flows have 13x higher placed order rates than campaigns. Here's the order I'd build:

  1. Welcome series, with most of the work in email #1.
  2. Abandoned checkout, abandoned cart and browse abandonment. Sleep shoppers compare a lot. Answer the "will this work for me?" question with reviews and your return policy.
  3. Post-purchase, teaching people how to use what they bought so they stick with it.
  4. Reorder or subscription reminder, if your product runs out.
  5. Cross-sell, timed by product.
  6. Winback. For replenishable products, I email customers with no order in 60 days to bring them back into an educational cycle, still with a reason to buy.

Two settings to check. I keep Smart Sending off on automations so nobody misses a reminder they need, and on for normal campaigns. More in Klaviyo Smart Sending.

And with the holidays here, plan for January now. I like a 3-email January series to people who placed their first order in November or December. It's not the only thing you send in January, but it's a good way to turn holiday first-timers into repeat customers. More ideas in January email marketing ideas.

What numbers should a sleep brand watch?

  • Revenue per recipient for content-only sends vs content plus a reason to buy. That comparison tells you if your education is selling.
  • Revenue per delivery for welcome email #1.
  • Click rate. Klaviyo's 2026 benchmarks put a good click rate at 1.69% for campaigns and 5.58% for flows.
  • Placed order rate. There's no sleep category in Klaviyo's benchmarks. Health and beauty sits at 1.02% for campaigns and 1.65% for flows; home and garden at 1.34% and 2.17%. Use whichever is closer to what you sell.

Where these numbers come from

The welcome email #1 and education numbers come from one sleep wellness brand, and the subscription reminder number comes from one subscription wellness brand. The per-person numbers come from a pooled look at 4 brands. Single-brand results depend on the product, the list and the starting point, so treat them as examples, not benchmarks.

FAQ

Should sleep brands send educational emails?

Yes, but never on their own. Teach one thing, connect it to the product and give one reason to buy. At a sleep wellness brand, a month of education-only campaigns took campaign revenue from $3,146 to $110.

How long should a sleep brand's welcome series be?

Klaviyo's guide suggests 3 emails over about a week. Whatever the length, put most of your effort into email #1, where most of the money is.

Can I say my product helps people sleep better?

Be careful. The FTC says health-related claims need competent and reliable scientific evidence, and implied claims count too. Have a lawyer review anything that touches health.

What's a good email click rate for a sleep brand?

Klaviyo's 2026 benchmarks put a good click rate at 1.69% for campaigns and 5.58% for flows. Clicks matter only if they turn into orders, so watch revenue per recipient too.

Jack White, founder of Bardown Digital
WRITTEN BY Jack White

Founder of Bardown Digital, a Chicago-based Klaviyo email and retention agency for Shopify brands. He's worked with brands doing $500K to $100M a year, with $100M+ in email-attributed revenue across them.

SOURCES

Keep reading

All posts →
BY BRAND TYPE · 9 MIN READ

Email marketing for consumer tech brands: win the long decision, then sell the accessories

Consumer electronics email marketing: answer spec questions in abandonment flows, ask for the sale, time accessory emails, and lean into gift season.

Read the post →
BY BRAND TYPE · 9 MIN READ

Email marketing for clothing brands: drops, restocks and sizes

Email marketing for clothing brands on Shopify: how to run drops, restock and low stock emails, size-aware back in stock, and which flows to build first.

Read the post →
BY BRAND TYPE · 8 MIN READ

Email marketing for jewelry brands: gifting, milestones and trust

Jewelry email marketing for Shopify brands: gifting lines in your flows, holiday timing, birthday and anniversary flows, and emails that build trust.

Read the post →

Want me to look at your sleep brand's emails?

If your campaigns are mostly education and revenue feels flat, that's where I'd start. The first strategy session is free: one hour, live with me in your Klaviyo account, and you leave with a fix list even if we never work together. Not ready to book? Grab one of my free resources instead.

Book a strategy session
Or email me at jackwhite@bardowndigital.com