STRATEGY

Cyber Monday emails: how to run the last day of BFCM without burning your list

A good Cyber Monday email plan is two or three emails on the day: a morning "last day" send, an afternoon reminder to people who haven't bought, and a final "ends tonight" email a few hours before the deadline. Cyber Monday is November 30, 2026, and it's the biggest online shopping day of the year, so the goal is to be clear, not loud. This is for Shopify founders using Klaviyo who want to close out BFCM strong without wrecking their list for December.

Jack White
Jack White Founder, Bardown Digital
Updated · 7 min read
KEY TAKEAWAYS
  • Cyber Monday is the biggest US online shopping day. Adobe reported $14.25 billion in online spend in 2025 and forecasts $15.1 billion for 2026.
  • Plan two or three emails on the day, plus one or two texts. Every send needs a reason.
  • Say what they'll get and where. A crafty subject line costs you on the busiest inbox day of the year.
  • Turn Smart Sending off on Cyber Monday, or your afternoon and evening sends will skip people who got the morning one.
  • Exclude people who already bought. The last-call email is for people who haven't.

How big is Cyber Monday for email?

Big. Adobe reported that consumers spent $14.25 billion online on Cyber Monday 2025, up 7.1% year over year, making it the largest online shopping day of the year. Adobe forecasts $15.1 billion for Cyber Monday 2026.

On Klaviyo's side, its BFCM 2025 results showed Cyber Monday revenue up 11% year over year, with Cyber Sunday growing nearly 14%, the fastest-growing day of the weekend. Email and text together drove 42% of total revenue for Klaviyo brands over BFCM.

And for your own list: BFCM emails typically get 2 to 5x the results of a regular campaign, and the range varies by brand. Cyber Monday is the last day of that window. It's worth planning on its own, not as an afterthought to Black Friday.

How many emails should you send on Cyber Monday?

Two or three for most brands. Here's the schedule I'd start with:

When Email Who gets it
Sunday evening (optional) "Cyber Monday starts now" or "Tomorrow's the last day" Engaged list
Monday morning Last day: the offer, the end time, the best sellers Engaged list
Monday afternoon Reminder, or a different angle (bundles, gift picks) Engaged list minus anyone who bought over BFCM
Monday, a few hours before the end Ends tonight. One message, one link. Same as the afternoon send

If you're running a separate Cyber Monday offer (some brands switch to a new deal on Monday), make that the first line of the morning email. If it's the same sale continuing, say so plainly: "Last day for 25% off."

Keep the final email short. By that point people know what you're selling. The only new information is the deadline.

What should a Cyber Monday email say?

What they'll get, where to get it, and when it ends. In that order.

The most common Black Friday subject line mistake I see is being too crafty. Retention-channel customers want to know what they'll get and where. That's even more true on Cyber Monday, when your email lands next to every other brand's. Compare:

  • "Last day: 25% off everything ends at midnight PT"
  • "Don't let this one get away..."

The first one tells you everything in eight words. The second makes you open to find out, and on Cyber Monday a lot of people won't.

A few more rules for the body of the email:

  • Put the offer and end time above the fold. Not under a hero image.
  • Show best sellers, not your whole catalog. People decide faster with fewer choices.
  • State the time zone. "Midnight" means three different things across the US.
  • Don't fake the deadline. If the sale really ends Monday, say so. If you plan to extend it, don't send an "ends tonight" email. The FTC's staff report on dark patterns calls out countdown timers on offers that aren't actually time-limited.

For more subject line ideas, see my Black Friday email subject lines. The same thinking applies on Monday.

Should you turn Smart Sending off on Cyber Monday?

Yes. Klaviyo's Smart Sending stops someone from getting a message if they got one recently. By default the window is 16 hours for email and 24 hours for SMS. That means your afternoon and evening Cyber Monday emails will skip anyone who got your morning email, which is most of your list.

I keep Smart Sending on for normal campaigns. I turn it off for restocks, deadlines, launches and multi-send BFCM days, and on automations so people don't miss critical reminders. Cyber Monday is all of those at once. On heavy send days I don't change anything in my flows. I just make sure Smart Sending is off. More in Klaviyo Smart Sending.

How do you send more on Cyber Monday without burning your list?

Be smart about who gets each send.

  • Exclude recent buyers from the afternoon and evening emails. Someone who bought on Black Friday doesn't need three "last chance" emails on Monday. Build a segment of people who placed an order since the sale started and exclude it.
  • Send the extra emails to engaged people. Your morning email can go wider. The reminders should go to people who've opened or clicked recently.
  • Don't send the final email at 11 p.m. Send it with a few hours left so people can still act on it.

The goal is that the people who get three emails on Monday are the people who were most likely to buy anyway. Everyone else gets one or two.

How should texts and emails work together on Cyber Monday?

Texts are reminders. Emails are branding and awareness. On Cyber Monday, use texts to remind people to read the email or to flag the deadline.

A simple pairing: email in the morning with the full offer, a text in the early afternoon ("Last day for 25% off. Details in your inbox or shop here"), and a final email or text a few hours before the end. Plan both channels in the same calendar so the text always lands after the email it points to.

My full texting plan for the weekend is in Black Friday SMS.

What if your Cyber Monday sale is a flash sale?

Some brands skip a weekend-long sale and run a single-day Cyber Monday deal. That changes the rhythm: you get one announcement and one or two reminders, all on the same day, with the deadline doing most of the work. I cover that format in flash sale emails.

And when Cyber Monday is over, close it out. Send nothing on Tuesday that pretends the sale is still running. Your next job is December: shipping cutoffs and gift buyers. Start with the BFCM email strategy if you're still building the whole weekend.

FAQ

How many emails should I send on Cyber Monday?

Two or three: a morning "last day" email, an afternoon reminder to people who haven't bought, and an "ends tonight" email a few hours before the end.

What time should I send Cyber Monday emails?

Morning for the main send, early afternoon for the reminder, and early evening for the last call. Don't wait until the final hour.

Should I extend my sale past Cyber Monday?

That's a business call. If you're going to extend, don't send "ends tonight" emails first. Telling people a deal ends when it doesn't is the kind of false urgency the FTC warns about.

Should Cyber Monday emails go to my whole list?

The first one can go to your normal engaged audience. The reminders should exclude people who already bought during BFCM.

What's a good Cyber Monday subject line?

One that says the offer and the deadline. "Last day: 25% off ends at midnight PT" beats anything clever.

Jack White, founder of Bardown Digital
WRITTEN BY Jack White

Founder of Bardown Digital, a Chicago-based Klaviyo email and retention agency for Shopify brands. He's worked with brands doing $500K to $100M a year, with $100M+ in email-attributed revenue across them.

SOURCES

Keep reading

All posts →
STRATEGY · 7 MIN READ

Klaviyo flows vs campaigns: what each does and what split to aim for

Klaviyo flows vs campaigns for Shopify brands: what each one does, why flows earn more per send, and the revenue split to watch in your account.

Read the post →
STRATEGY · 7 MIN READ

Christmas email subject lines that say what they sell

Christmas email subject lines for Shopify brands by send: gift guides, shipping cutoffs, last-minute gifts, Christmas Day and Boxing Day, plus what to avoid.

Read the post →
STRATEGY · 7 MIN READ

Last chance emails: how to write the final-hours send that closes a sale

How to write a last chance email for a Shopify sale: when to send it, what the subject line and body should say, who to exclude, and how to keep it honest.

Read the post →

Finish BFCM strong

Cyber Monday is the last big push of the weekend and the busiest inbox day of the year. The first strategy session is free: one hour, live with me in your Klaviyo account, and you leave with a fix list even if we never work together. Not ready to book? Grab one of my free resources instead.

Book a strategy session
Or email me at jackwhite@bardowndigital.com