FLOWS

Back in stock email subject lines (and why three words can win)

The best back in stock email subject lines are short and say exactly one thing: the product is back. "It's back," "[Product] is back in stock" or "We're back baby!" will usually beat a clever line, because the person who signed up for the alert already knows what they want. The subject line just has to tell them it's time. Below are subject lines you can use for back in stock flows and restock campaigns, one real result from a snack brand, and the Klaviyo settings that matter as much as the words. This is for Shopify founders using Klaviyo who sell products that sell out.

Jack White
Jack White Founder, Bardown Digital
Updated · 7 min read
KEY TAKEAWAYS
  • Keep it short and plain. The news is "it's back." Lead with it.
  • Restock emails can be a brand's best send. A snack brand's "We're back baby!" made $48,771 from 30,498 people, its top campaign ever.
  • Back in stock emails earned about 1.7x the average email per person for that brand ($0.26 vs $0.15).
  • Turn Smart Sending off for restock sends, so people who asked to be told actually get told.
  • Click every link before you send. A restock email with great clicks and no sales usually means something broke.

What makes a good back in stock subject line?

It says the product is back, in as few words as possible.

Think about who's reading it. Someone who signed up for a back in stock alert raised their hand for one specific product. They don't need to be persuaded. They need to know it's available, and ideally which product, if they're waiting on more than one.

The most common mistake I see in Black Friday subject lines is being too crafty. Retention-channel customers want to know what they'll get and where. Restock emails are the purest version of that rule. "Something you love just came home" makes them guess. "[Product] is back" doesn't.

Across 2,821 campaigns from 7 brands, news beat brand voice, and "it's back" is about as newsy as a subject line gets.

Back in stock email subject lines to use

These are templates written for this post. Swap [Product] for your product name, or leave it out for a store-wide restock.

For back in stock flows (sent to people who signed up for an alert) - [Product] is back in stock - It's back: [Product] - You asked, it's here: [Product] - Back in stock, [first name] - Your [Product] is ready to order

For restock campaigns (sent to your list) - We're back baby! - It's back. - [Product] is back (for now) - Restocked: [Product] - The [Product] restock is live

When stock is genuinely limited - [Product] is back. Small batch this time. - Back in stock, and going fast last time - Restocked today. Last time it sold out in [X days].

Only use the limited lines if they're true. If you write "going fast," it should be going fast.

Can a three-word subject line really win?

It can. A snack brand doing about $650K a month sent a restock email with the subject line "We're back baby!" It made $48,771 from 30,498 people, the brand's top campaign ever. Six of its restock emails each made over $16,000.

Across that brand's sends, back in stock emails earned about 1.7x the average email per person: $0.26 versus $0.15.

Three words, no product name, no discount. It worked because the audience already wanted the product and the email told them, plainly and with some personality, that it was available. Short subject lines force you to pick the one thing that matters.

That's one brand's result, not a guarantee. But it shows how much a plain restock email can do when the audience already wants the product.

Why would a restock email get clicks but no sales?

Usually because something broke. A strength training gear brand's restock email hit a 0.40% click rate, double every other send that month, and made $0.

When clicks are high and sales are zero, check:

  • Did the product sell out again before people got to it?
  • Does the link work and go to the right product?
  • Does the landing page work on mobile, with the right variant in stock?

The lesson: click every link before you hit send, and check stock right before a restock campaign goes out. I cover the other causes in email clicks but no sales.

How does Klaviyo decide who gets a back in stock email?

The subject line only matters if the email reaches people. In Klaviyo, a back in stock flow is triggered by the "Subscribed to Back in Stock" metric, which is tracked when someone signs up for an alert on an out-of-stock product. They then wait in the flow until your back in stock settings release them.

Those settings live in Klaviyo's back in stock settings, and three of them shape who gets the email:

  • Restock minimum. How many units need to be restocked before Klaviyo notifies subscribers.
  • Batch size. How many subscribers to notify for each restocked item.
  • Notification frequency. How often to send the next batch, in hours or days.

By default Klaviyo notifies everyone at once, and it notifies the people who have been waiting longest first. If you batch, Klaviyo keeps sending batches until inventory drops below your minimum. One catch from Klaviyo's docs: after the first message in the flow, Klaviyo can't check inventory again. So if you add a second email, make sure it still makes sense if the product sold out in the meantime.

If you have a small restock and a big waitlist, batching helps you avoid emailing thousands of people about 50 units. The setup steps are in Klaviyo back in stock emails.

Should Smart Sending be off for back in stock emails?

Yes. I keep Smart Sending on for normal campaigns, and turn it off for restocks, deadlines, launches and multi-send BFCM days, and on automations, so people don't miss critical reminders.

Klaviyo's Smart Sending skips someone if they got a message recently. The default window is 16 hours for email and 24 hours for SMS. If someone got your newsletter this morning and their product came back this afternoon, Smart Sending could skip the one email they actually asked for. More in Klaviyo Smart Sending.

What should the rest of the email say?

Keep it as plain as the subject line:

  1. The product, with a photo, right at the top.
  2. One button straight to the product page.
  3. A reason to act now, only if it's true: limited stock, sold out last time.
  4. A second product for people who want to add to their order, if it fits.

No long story needed. For more on subject lines in general, see email subject line best practices.

FAQ

What's a good subject line for a back in stock email?

Something short that says the product is back: "[Product] is back in stock," "It's back," or "We're back baby!"

Should I include the product name in the subject line?

In a back in stock flow, yes, especially if people may be waiting on more than one product. For a store-wide restock campaign, a short "It's back" can work.

Do back in stock emails make money?

They can. For one snack brand, back in stock emails earned about 1.7x the average email per person, and a single restock email made $48,771.

Should I add urgency to back in stock subject lines?

Only if it's true. "Small batch" or "sold out last time" works when it's accurate. Don't invent scarcity.

Why didn't everyone on my waitlist get the email?

Check your restock minimum and batch settings in Klaviyo, and whether Smart Sending was on. Klaviyo notifies the longest-waiting subscribers first when you batch.

Jack White, founder of Bardown Digital
WRITTEN BY Jack White

Founder of Bardown Digital, a Chicago-based Klaviyo email and retention agency for Shopify brands. He's worked with brands doing $500K to $100M a year, with $100M+ in email-attributed revenue across them.

SOURCES

Keep reading

All posts →
FLOWS · 6 MIN READ

Browse abandonment email subject lines that get the second look

Browse abandonment email subject lines for Shopify brands: what to write, templates to start from, and the Klaviyo settings that decide who gets them.

Read the post →
FLOWS · 12 MIN READ

Browse abandonment email: a lighter touch that still sells

How browse abandonment emails work in Klaviyo, when to send them, three example emails, and the filters that keep the flow from overlapping cart.

Read the post →
FLOWS · 7 MIN READ

SMS post-purchase upsell: what to text after the first order

Post-purchase SMS upsell for Shopify brands: when to send the first text after an order, what it should say, and how to keep it from repeating your emails.

Read the post →

Make your restock emails count

A product that sells out is a list of people waiting to buy. The first strategy session is free: one hour, live with me in your Klaviyo account, and you leave with a fix list even if we never work together. Not ready to book? Grab one of my free resources instead.

Book a strategy session
Or email me at jackwhite@bardowndigital.com